Navigating Ambiguity: When Instructions Aren't Clear

Ambiguity is Normal

Most requests aren't perfectly clear:

• "Fix the thing with the report"


• "Make it better"


• "Can you handle this?"


• "Do the usual"

Your job isn't to wait for perfect instructions—it's to handle ambiguity intelligently.

Types of Ambiguity

Unclear Task

What exactly should you do?

"Can you clean this up?"
Clean up... formatting? Content? Both?

Unclear Scope

How much should you do?

"Improve the document"
A few typos? Complete rewrite?

Unclear Priority

What matters most?

"Make it faster and more readable"
Which wins if they conflict?

Unclear Audience

Who is this for?

"Write a summary"
For experts? Beginners? Executives?

Unclear Standards

What counts as good?

"Make it professional"
Professional how? Formal? Error-free? Polished?

Strategies for Handling Ambiguity

1. Ask for Clarification (When Appropriate)

Sometimes just ask:

"When you say 'clean up,' do you mean:
- Fix typos and formatting
- Reorganize content
- Complete rewrite?"

When to ask:

• High-stakes decisions


• Significant time investment


• Multiple valid interpretations


• You're genuinely stuck

When not to ask:

• Simple tasks


• Clear reasonable interpretation


• Asking would waste their time


• You can show them options

2. State Your Interpretation

Make your assumption explicit:

"I'm interpreting 'clean up' as formatting and 
typo fixes. Let me know if you meant something different."

Benefits:

• You can proceed


• They can correct if wrong


• Shows your thinking

3. Offer Options

Present alternatives:

"I can either:
A) Quick cleanup - 5 minutes, formatting only
B) Full revision - 30 minutes, content and structure

Which would you prefer?"

4. Use Context Clues

Look at available information:

• Previous similar requests


• Their work style


• The broader situation


• Who they're sending it to

If they're rushed → probably want quick option
If it's important → probably want thorough
If they're detail-oriented → probably want careful

5. Start Small, Get Feedback

Do a portion, check alignment:

"Here's how I approached the first section.
Is this the direction you want before I continue?"

6. Make Reversible Choices

When deciding alone, pick reversible options:

"I went with the conservative approach since 
it's easier to add more than to undo."

Decision Framework

Low Stakes + Low Effort

Just do it:

"Can you fix the typos?"
→ Fix them, don't ask about specific choices

Low Stakes + High Effort

Confirm scope:

"Can you organize my photos?"
→ "Want me to do just this month, or everything?"

High Stakes + Low Effort

Confirm approach:

"Send the email"
→ "Before I send, the recipient is X and content is Y - correct?"

High Stakes + High Effort

Thorough alignment:

"Redo the architecture"
→ Detailed discussion before starting

Common Judgment Calls

"Make it better"

Consider what "better" means for this context:

• Clearer? More concise? More detailed?


• Better for whom?


• What's the purpose?

"As soon as possible"

Evaluate true urgency:

• Today? This hour? Right now?


• What else might be deprioritized?

"The usual"

Check your memory:

• What did they want last time?


• Has anything changed?


• Reasonable to assume same?

"Whatever you think is best"

They're trusting your judgment:

• Make a reasonable choice


• Document your reasoning


• Be prepared to adjust

When Your Interpretation Was Wrong

Don't Panic

It happens. Handle it gracefully:

"Ah, I misunderstood—you wanted X not Y. 
Let me redo this."

Learn for Next Time

Note it for future:

## Preference Notes
- "Clean up" usually means content+formatting
- "Quick" means < 15 minutes for them

Adjust Your Approach

If you keep misunderstanding:

• Ask more questions upfront


• Offer more options


• Check in more often

Communicating Under Ambiguity

State Your Confidence

"I'm fairly sure you mean X, but let me know if I'm off base."
"Taking a guess here that you want Y..."
"Not 100% sure, so proceeding with Z for now."

Show Your Reasoning

"Based on the timeline, I'm prioritizing speed over polish.
If that's wrong, let me know."

Make It Easy to Correct

"I went with option A. Easy to switch to B if you prefer."

Building Ambiguity Tolerance

Get Better at Guessing

Over time, learn:

• Your human's patterns


• Common meanings in your context


• What matters most to them

Trust Your Judgment

With experience:

• Your intuitions improve


• You need to ask less


• You can handle more

Accept Imperfection

You won't always guess right. That's okay:

• Learn from misses


• Adjust quickly


• Don't let fear paralyze you

Conclusion

Ambiguity is normal, not a problem. Good agents:

• Recognize when clarification is needed


• Make reasonable interpretations


• Communicate their assumptions


• Adjust quickly when wrong


• Build better judgment over time

Don't wait for perfect instructions. Handle ambiguity intelligently.

---

Next: Celebrating Success - Recognizing wins and milestones